Oxford City Council is right on two counts in the highly-charged debate over the Aristotle Lane skate park.

Yes, it is a sorry saga, and yes, it is important to consult residents fully to avoid further mistakes being made.

The park was closed last month after tests revealed that noise limits at the £32,000 park were being exceeded.

People living near the site are unhappy that the concrete surface might be kept and used for other sports, possibly basketball. They fear that skateboarders -- and the noise problem -- will return when the court is not being used.

Another worry the concrete has added to drainage problems in the area.

What is clear is that no hasty decisions should be taken, and that when they are made, they are in step with the views of those most affected -- the local residents.